: One of the best non-hybrid options available, achieving up to 36 MPG combined (32 city/42 highway). It is widely recommended by Dream Work Automotive for its ability to hold its resale value remarkably well.
: The LE trim is a well-rounded city and highway option, delivering roughly 35 MPG combined without any hybrid components.
: For buyers on a strict budget, the Versa is one of the most affordable 5-year-old cars on the market. Despite its low entry price, it still manages up to 40 MPG on the highway. Comparison of Top Fuel-Efficient Used Sedans MPG (Combined) Annual Fuel Cost (Approx.) Toyota Prius Hyundai Elantra Hybrid Toyota Camry Hybrid Honda Civic Toyota Corolla best mileage used cars to buy
: If buying a hybrid older than 8 years, ensure the hybrid battery has been tested, as replacements can be costly.
Prius ( Toyota Prius ) is a great looking car, especially the current gen. Most of Toyotas hybrids are rock solid options. Toyota Prius Nissan Sentra : One of the best non-hybrid options available,
For the absolute best fuel economy, hybrids remain the gold standard, especially for city commuters who benefit from regenerative braking. Toyota Camry Camry is a car by Toyota. Toyota Camry Toyota Corolla The car is a Toyota Corolla. Toyota Corolla Toyota Prius
Annual fuel cost data based on 2026 EPA estimates from Yahoo Autos . Pro Tips for Buying Fuel-Efficient Used Cars : For buyers on a strict budget, the
: This model is often cited by experts from U.S. News as a top "value" pick, offering up to 54 MPG combined and standing out for its high reliability scores.