The episode follows three strangers living in the opulent on New York City's Upper West Side who bond over their shared obsession with a true-crime podcast called All Is Not OK in Oklahoma .

The premiere opens with a scene set two months in the future, showing Charles and Oliver discovering Mabel kneeling over a different dead body in the building. Production & Trivia

A misanthropic, semi-retired actor known for his 1990s detective show, Brazzos .

A young, guarded woman who is supposedly renovating her aunt's apartment.