[s1e3] Smile, Or Go To Jail May 2026

The "case of the week" follows Paula Murphy (guest star Ana Ortiz ), a suburban "soccer mom" arrested for a minor misdemeanor. However, as she is about to be released, she is rearrested by the FBI under an alias for a 1994 felony murder involving a bombing. Annalise Keating and her students must prove her innocence, which hinges on the testimony of another suspect in that decades-old case.

: Wes Gibbins’ determination leads Annalise to officially take on Rebecca Sutter as a client. [S1E3] Smile, or Go to Jail

: Detective Nate Lahey investigates Sam Keating’s alibi for the night of Lila Stangard's murder. He discovers the alibi does not check out but lies to Annalise , telling her Sam was where he claimed to be. The "case of the week" follows Paula Murphy